Finding an equilibrium between the two would be best, I think. But I have always been a diplomat at heart. [It's how he managed to build the greatest alliance of the First Age. Too bad Ulfang and his sons stabbed him in the back and ruined it for everyone!]
[He can tell you don't believe him. That's fine though, he knew he could back it up if ever asked for proof.] It is not a good feeling, I can tell you that much. I watched those boys grow and nurtured them as best I could... it tore at my heart to send them away but it had to be done. I knew I did not have long left before I'd need to leave them anyways. This way at least I'd known I'd given them the best chance I could.
No one knows. Not even Mandos knows where your kind goes, or if he does he does not speak of it. We have theories, sure. But we do not know.
Probably not. Still... an Elf would know if their soul was being munched on
[He can tell you don't believe him. That's fine though, he knew he could back it up if ever asked for proof.] It is not a good feeling, I can tell you that much. I watched those boys grow and nurtured them as best I could... it tore at my heart to send them away but it had to be done. I knew I did not have long left before I'd need to leave them anyways. This way at least I'd known I'd given them the best chance I could.
No one knows. Not even Mandos knows where your kind goes, or if he does he does not speak of it. We have theories, sure. But we do not know.