The guy is speechless. How adorable. Finnick is used to being brushed off far more easily. He believes that John doesn't get compliments often, if he's this touched by them.

"Well now, that's just criminal. A man like you should feel confident in himself. Though I must admit, the bashfulness is very cute." He speaks low and is still leaned in close, like he's telling John a secret.

"Did I ever even tell you my name? I'm Finnick." He holds his hand out to shake, but he's still so close that it's more like he's trying to hold John's hand.